top of page
Search

From Picky to Playful — Feeding Toddlers Without Pressure or Panic

Research-supported; mum-of-three observations — not medical advice.


ree

If feeding a baby felt like a full-time job, feeding a toddler might feel like an emotional negotiation. One day they love broccoli. The next they treat it like a personal insult. One day they eat three full meals. The next their entire calorie intake is… raisins.

Welcome to toddler feeding — where “picky” is normal, mess is guaranteed, and pressure only makes everything harder.

Here’s the calm, compassionate, evidence-based guide to navigating food from ages 1–3 without losing your sanity.


Why Toddler Feeding Changes So Dramatically


1. Appetite naturally drops

Growth slows after age one — meaning appetite dips. This is normal, not a feeding problem.

2. Toddlers are biologically cautious

This is called neophobia (fear of new foods).It peaks between 18–24 months. It’s protective, not defiant.

3. They want control

Eating is one of the few areas toddlers control completely. Pressuring usually backfires.

4. They’re distracted by everything

Toddlers have better things to do than sit still and eat — like emptying your cupboards.


How Much Should Toddlers Eat? (Spoiler: Less Than You Think)


Typical toddler portions are about ¼ of an adult portion.

Example portions:

  • 2–3 tablespoons of veg

  • Half a slice of toast

  • 1–2 tablespoons of pasta

  • A few bites of chicken/fish

  • A handful of soft fruit

Small portions help food feel less overwhelming.


A Typical Day’s Food (NHS Start for Life)


Breakfast

  • Porridge with fruit

  • Eggs

  • Toast + peanut butter

Lunch

  • Hummus, soft veg, pita

  • Pasta + cheese

  • Omelette + salad bits

Dinner

  • Fish pie

  • Soft stew

  • Stir fry with noodles

Snacks

  • Fruit

  • Yoghurt

  • Cheese

  • Rice cakes

  • Mini sandwiches

Variety beats perfection.

Picky Eating: The Normal, Annoying Stage


It’s normal if your toddler:

  • Eats well some days and barely anything others

  • Rejects foods they previously loved

  • Prefers carbs

  • Refuses new foods

  • Makes faces at unfamiliar textures

  • Wants the same meal 4 days in a row

You're not doing anything wrong. This is development, not judgement on your cooking.


Evidence-Based Strategies That Actually Work


1. The Division of Responsibility (Ellyn Satter Model)

You decide: what, when, where. Your toddler decides: if and how much

Game-changing.

2. Repeated Exposure

A toddler may need 10–20 exposures before accepting a new food. A refusal is not a “no forever.”


3. Eat Together When Possible

Toddlers copy you far more than they listen to you.


4. Offer Safe Foods + Challenge Foods

A balanced plate might include:

  • One “safe” food (pasta, bread, fruit)

  • One accepted food

  • One new food

  • One veggie

This reduces pressure while encouraging variety.


5. Let Them Play With Food (Yes, Really)

Sensory exploration is how toddlers learn. Messy eating helps them accept textures and flavours.


6. Avoid Pressure & Praise

Avoid:

  • “One more bite”

  • “Just try it for me”

  • Bribes or rewards

Pressure reduces appetite. Let curiosity lead.


7. Serve Food Family-Style

Small bowls on the table let toddlers choose what goes on their plate. This gives autonomy and reduces battles.


8. Keep Meals Short & Calm

10–20 minutes is realistic. Toddler attention spans expire quickly.


Drinks & Milk for Toddlers

After 12 months:


  • Whole cow’s milk is OK as a drink

  • Formula not required (unless you choose to)

  • Breastfeeding can continue as long as you both want

  • Water should be the main drink

  • Limit juice (diluted, mealtimes only)


Supplements (NHS Guidance)

Give vitamin A, C & D daily from 6 months to 5 years, unless drinking more than 500ml formula per day.


When to Seek Support (NHS & RCPCH)


Speak to a health visitor or GP if:

  • Your toddler eats fewer than 10 foods consistently

  • Weight gain is a concern

  • Mealtimes are extremely stressful every day

  • They cough/gag often with food

  • They avoid entire food groups

  • There are sensory concerns

  • Severe constipation is affecting appetite

You're not being dramatic — feeding is fundamental.


Local Support (Farnborough & Surrounding Areas)


Health Visiting Teams


For growth monitoring, feeding guidance and referral to dietitians.


Family & Children’s Centres


Offer:

  • Fussy eating workshops

  • Weaning-to-toddler-eating groups

  • Growth/weight checks

Based in Farnborough, Fleet, Aldershot, Guildford, Woking, Camberley.


NHS Dietitian Referral


Available via Frimley Health & Royal Surrey for feeding concerns or nutritional needs.


SALT (Speech & Language Therapy)

For suspected swallowing or feeding mechanics issues.


In Short


Toddler feeding isn’t about “clean plates” — it’s about confidence, autonomy and exploration. Your toddler is learning what food means to them, and that takes time.

Offer variety. Stay consistent. Breathe through the mess. And know that you’re doing brilliantly — even on the days dinner ends up on the floor.


References

Comments

bottom of page